Lead Stories, Sports

Mamaroneck repeats as Section 1 champs

For the second consecutive year, Mamaroneck is the king of Section 1 Class AA football. But for the Tigers, Saturday night’s championship came with a little something extra: revenge.

Behind a brilliant performance from quarterback James Fitzgerald, three touchdown catches from Sam Mehler and a relentless second-half defensive effort, Mamaroneck defeated Arlington 28-14 at North Rockland High School, capturing its second straight sectional crown while avenging a 34-7 September loss to the Admirals.

Mamaroneck celebrates its second-straight Section 1 title on Saturday, Nov. 14.

“It makes it so much sweeter; when we saw Arlington had won their semifinal game, everybody was ecstatic because this is the game we wanted, we knew this time we could beat them,” Fitzgerald said. “Last time we had just come off a big win and we were sleeping when we went up there; we couldn’t get off the bus. This time, we gave a full effort all week and it showed up in the end.”

Fitzgerald was sensational, completing 16 of 22 passes for 220 yards and four touchdowns while adding 71 rushing yards on 12 carries. Mehler was equally impressive, hauling in nine passes for 174 yards and three scores. 

The Tigers (8-3) struck first on a 10-yard Fitzgerald touchdown pass to Nick Laboy, but Arlington answered with a five-yard scoring connection between quarterback Nick Keenan and Jordan Pease.

Fitzgerald found Mehler for a 36-yard touchdown early in the second quarter, but Arlington’s Mikey Fortuna broke loose for a 26-yard scoring run to send the teams into halftime tied 14-14.

From there, Mamaroneck’s defense took control.

The Tigers repeatedly frustrated Arlington’s offense, coming up with crucial stops and takeaways that allowed Fitzgerald and company to seize momentum.

“It’s all about momentum. I threw two picks today and that’s not great, but they just bounced back gave that momentum right back to the offense,” Fitzgerald said. “And you could feel that in the huddle.”

A particularly important defensive stand pinned Arlington deep in its own territory during the third quarter. Following an Admirals punt, Fitzgerald immediately connected with Mehler for a 30-yard touchdown, giving Mamaroneck a 21-14 advantage.

With just over three minutes remaining, Fitzgerald delivered the knockout blow, finding Mehler for a 65-yard touchdown that sealed the victory. 

“Last time we played, they were playing pretty far back, but today they were playing up, so we knew we had a chance to take some shots and that worked out well for us,” Mehler said. “This is my first time playing in a section championship game and performing well felt great.”

For Mamaroneck, which has now reached four sectional championship games in five seasons, Saturday’s victory reinforced a growing championship tradition.

“It shows they’re champions and champions die hard,” said head coach Anthony Vitti said. “All week, we talked about how this was our ecosystem; we’re used to this, we’ve been here four of the last five years and it was really just about closing. The fear of having someone take what you’ve worked for can be a great motivator, so finishing the job was really our purpose this week.”

Up next for the Tigers is a showdown with Section 6 Lancaster on Saturday, Nov. 21, at 3 p.m. at Mahopac High School.